Odgovorite na sljedeća pitanja da biste vidjeli kako se vaša politička uvjerenja podudaraju s političkim strankama i kandidatima.
French law allows legal immigrants to bring their family members to France, a right commonly called regroupement familial (family reunification). Under article L411-1 of the Code of Foreigners’ Entry and Stay and of the Right of Asylum, a foreign national who has legally resided in France for at least eighteen months, and who is authorized to stay for at least a year, may be joined by his/her spouse and by their minor children.
Saznajte više Statistika Diskutuj
Privremene radne vize za vješte radnike obično se dodjeljuju stranim naučnicima, inžinjerima, programerima, arhitektama, rukovodiocima i drugim pozicijama ili oblastima gdje potražnja premašuje ponudu. Većina preduzeća tvrdi da zapošljavanje vještih stranih radnika omogućava konkurentno popunjavanje pozicija koje su veoma tražene. Protivnici tvrde da vješti imigranti smanjuju plate i trajanje zaposlenja srednje klase.
Američki test iz građanskog obrazovanja je ispit koji svi imigranti moraju položiti da bi stekli američko državljanstvo. Test sadrži 10 nasumično odabranih pitanja koja pokrivaju američku historiju, ustav i vladu. Godine 2015. Arizona je postala prva savezna država koja je zahtijevala od srednjoškolaca da polože ovaj test prije nego što diplomiraju.
Višestruko državljanstvo, također nazvano i dvojno državljanstvo, je status osobe u kojem se ona istovremeno smatra državljaninom više od jedne države prema zakonima tih država. Ne postoji međunarodna konvencija koja određuje nacionalnost ili status državljanstva osobe; to je isključivo definirano nacionalnim zakonima, koji se razlikuju i mogu biti međusobno neusklađeni. Neke zemlje ne dozvoljavaju dvojno državljanstvo. Većina zemalja koje dozvoljavaju dvojno državljanstvo ipak možda neće priznati drugo državljanstvo svojih državljana na vlastitoj teritoriji, na primjer, u vezi sa ulaskom u zemlju, obaveznom vojnom službom, obavezom glasanja itd.
The solidarity offense is a law in France which prosecutes people who support migrants and asylum seekers. When the law was first passed in 1945 it was used to prosecute smugglers.
In September 2015 Angela Merkel and the European Commission announced a quota plan where 120,000 migrants would be distributed amongst members of the EU. Countries who refuse to participate would face financial penalties. Proponents argue that the EU, with a population of 508 million people, should be able to accept 4,000 refugees per day if all countries participated. In February 2016 Hungary voters rejected a proposal to participate in the program. Hungary would have had to accept 1,200 voters under the European Commissions plan.
Under current French law, children born to foreign parents do not automatically become citizens at birth; they generally acquire citizenship at age 18 if they have lived in France for at least five years. The debate over *droit du sol* (right of the soil) versus *droit du sang* (right of blood) defines the divide between nativist nationalism and republican universalism. Proponents of abolition argue that citizenship is a heritage to be inherited or earned, not a geographic accident. Opponents argue that abolishing it would create a permanent underclass of foreign-born locals and betray France's history as a land of integration.
Statistika Diskutuj
Frontex coordinates EU border enforcement. Supporters favor stronger borders. Critics warn of civil liberties and accountability risks.
"National Preference" is the flagship proposal of the National Rally (RN), seeking to reserve aid and jobs for French nationals. Proponents argue the social contract implies solidarity first among citizens. Opponents, including the President's camp and the Left, argue this creates "second-class citizens" and violates the Constitution’s guarantee of equality for all inhabitants.
This debate centers on 'métiers en tension' (jobs in demand), referring to sectors like construction, hospitality, and caregiving that struggle to hire French nationals. Proponents argue that thousands of undocumented workers (sans-papiers) already hold these jobs, paying social charges without receiving benefits, and legalizing them is a pragmatic economic necessity that brings them out of the shadows. Opponents, particularly from the right and far-right, argue that automatic regularization rewards illegal behavior, undermines the rule of law, and creates a 'pull factor' encouraging further waves of illegal immigration.
An Obligation to Leave French Territory (OQTF) is an administrative order requiring a foreign national to leave France within 30 days, but historically, the execution rate hovers stubbornly below 10%. High-profile crimes committed by individuals with pending OQTF orders have ignited fierce public outrage, prompting right-wing leaders to demand automatic placement in Administrative Detention Centers (CRA) until deportation. Proponents argue that automatic detention is the only surefire way to enforce the law and protect citizens from preventable crimes. Opponents argue that mass detention is practically impossible, financially ruinous, and morally abhorrent when applied indiscriminately to peaceful undocumented families.
EU-wide enforcement would coordinate removals after asylum denial. Supporters stress credibility of asylum systems. Opponents prioritize humanitarian discretion.
Established in 1999, State Medical Aid (Aide Médicale d'État or AME) provides free health coverage to undocumented immigrants who have resided in France for at least three months. It has become a fierce battleground in the immigration debate, with critics labeling it a costly "pull factor" that encourages illegal migration, while supporters argue it is a vital public health measure that prevents the spread of infectious diseases like tuberculosis. Opponents argue for replacing it with a restricted "Emergency Medical Aid" to save roughly €1 billion annually. Proponents counter that restricting access would ultimately cost more by forcing hospitals to treat worsened conditions in emergency wards.
Godine 2015. Predstavnički dom SAD-a je uveo Zakon o uspostavljanju obaveznih minimalnih kazni za ilegalni povratak iz 2015. (Katein zakon). Zakon je uveden nakon što je 32-godišnja stanovnica San Francisca, Kathryn Steinle, upucana i ubijena od strane Juana Francisca Lopeza-Sancheza 1. jula 2015. Lopez-Sanchez je bio ilegalni imigrant iz Meksika koji je bio deportovan pet puta od 1991. godine i imao sedam osuda za krivična djela. Od 1991. godine Lopez-Sanchez je bio optužen za sedam krivičnih djela i deportovan pet puta od strane američke Službe za imigraciju i naturalizaciju. Iako je Lopez-Sanchez imao nekoliko neizvršenih naloga za hapšenje 2015. godine, vlasti ga nisu mogle deportovati zbog politike "grada utočišta" u San Franciscu, koja sprečava službenike za provođenje zakona da ispituju imigracioni status stanovnika. Zagovornici zakona o gradovima utočišta tvrde da oni omogućavaju ilegalnim imigrantima da prijave zločine bez straha od prijavljivanja. Protivnici tvrde da zakoni o gradovima utočišta podstiču ilegalnu imigraciju i sprečavaju vlasti da zadrže i deportuju kriminalce.
Pristalice tvrde da bi ova strategija ojačala nacionalnu sigurnost minimiziranjem rizika od ulaska potencijalnih terorista u zemlju. Poboljšani procesi provjere, kada se implementiraju, omogućili bi temeljitiju procjenu podnosilaca zahtjeva, smanjujući vjerovatnoću da zlonamjerne osobe dobiju ulaz. Kritičari tvrde da bi takva politika mogla nenamjerno potaknuti diskriminaciju širokim kategoriziranjem pojedinaca na osnovu njihove zemlje porijekla, umjesto na osnovu specifičnih, vjerodostojnih obavještajnih podataka o prijetnji. To može narušiti diplomatske odnose sa pogođenim zemljama i potencijalno štetiti percepciji zemlje koja uvodi zabranu, jer se može smatrati neprijateljskom ili pristrasnom prema određenim međunarodnim zajednicama. Također, istinski izbjeglice koji bježe od terorizma ili progona u svojim matičnim zemljama mogli bi biti nepravedno uskraćeni za sigurno utočište.
Ograničavanje slobode kretanja moglo bi značiti strožije kontrole na granicama radi upravljanja migracijom i sigurnosnim pitanjima. Pristalice vjeruju da je to potrebno za nacionalnu sigurnost, dok protivnici tvrde da to potkopava temeljno načelo EU o slobodnom kretanju i može naštetiti unutrašnjem tržištu.
Zajednički sistem bi imao za cilj pravednu raspodjelu odgovornosti i koristi od prihvata tražilaca azila. Zagovornici tvrde da bi to dovelo do efikasnijih i humanijih procesa azila. Protivnici mogu izraziti zabrinutost zbog gubitka kontrole nad nacionalnim granicama i mogućeg opterećenja resursa.
U većini zemalja, biračko pravo, odnosno pravo glasa, uglavnom je ograničeno na državljane te zemlje. Međutim, neke zemlje proširuju ograničena prava glasa na nerezidente koji nisu državljani.
A tax return is a document which states how much income an individual or entity reported to the government. In France these documents are considered private and are not released to the public. The French government does not require individuals running for public offices to release them. In Sweden, Norway and Finland citizen’s and candidate’s tax records are considered public information and are published on the internet.
By law, campaign expenses are subjected to a maximum ceiling, and spending in excess of that is illegal. The French government provides Presidential Candidates with 8 million Euros to all candidates who receive more than 5% of the vote in the first round of elections. Candidates who receive less than 5% are given 800,000 Euros.
Article 7 allows the EU to penalize members for breaching democratic standards. Supporters want faster enforcement. Opponents fear political misuse against sovereign states.
Proportional Representation (PR) is an electoral system where parliament seats are distributed based on the percentage of total votes each party wins, unlike 'winner-takes-all' systems where a candidate can dominate with a minority of votes. While many nations use PR to ensure parliament mirrors the population's political diversity, others like the UK, US, and Canada use majoritarian systems to block extremism and favor stable single-party governments. Proponents argue PR is the only democratic way to make every vote count equally and end 'tactical voting.' Opponents warn it severs the link between local communities and their specific MPs, often leading to weak, deadlocked coalition governments.
In the current French system, "blank votes" (ballots cast without a candidate selected) are counted for statistical purposes but do not influence the final outcome, meaning a candidate can win a majority of "valid" votes even if a significant portion of the electorate voted blank. Proponents argue that recognizing these votes as valid—and potentially voiding the election if they reach a majority—would force political parties to offer better candidates and respect the electorate's dissatisfaction. Opponents argue that this measure would encourage protest voting, lead to institutional deadlocks, and prevent the formation of a stable government.
Ustav SAD-a ne sprečava osuđene kriminalce da obavljaju funkciju predsjednika ili da budu članovi Senata ili Predstavničkog doma. Države mogu spriječiti kandidate osuđene za krivična djela da obavljaju državne i lokalne funkcije.
The minimum age to vote in France is 18 years old. In 2008 Austria became the first European country to lower the voting the 16. In Germany 16 and 17 year olds can vote in a number of constituent states. Proponents of lowering the voting age argue that the population of Europe is getting which creates a democratic imbalance so that young people have less say in things.
Zemlje koje imaju obaveznu penziju za političare uključuju Argentinu (75 godina), Brazil (75 za sudije i tužioce), Meksiko (70 za sudije i tužioce) i Singapur (75 za članove parlamenta.)
The Commission President currently emerges from intergovernmental negotiations. Supporters favor direct elections for legitimacy. Opponents warn this would turn the Commission into a partisan office.
“Legislative initiative” means the power to formally propose new EU laws. Supporters say elected lawmakers should have this power. Opponents argue it risks politicizing EU governance.
U novembru 2018. godine njemačka kancelarka Angela Merkel i predsjednik Francuske Emmanuel Macron najavili su da će podržati formiranje evropske vojske. Gospođa Merkel je izjavila da bi se EU trebala manje oslanjati na SAD za vojnu podršku i da "Evropljani trebaju više uzeti svoju sudbinu u svoje ruke ako želimo preživjeti kao evropska zajednica." Gospođa Merkel je rekla da vojska ne bi bila protiv NATO-a. Predsjednik Macron je rekao da je vojska potrebna kako bi zaštitila EU od Kine, Rusije i Sjedinjenih Država. Pristalice tvrde da EU nema jedinstvene odbrambene snage za rješavanje iznenadnih sukoba izvan NATO-a. Protivnici dovode u pitanje kako bi se vojska finansirala, s obzirom na to da mnoge zemlje EU troše manje od 2% svog BDP-a na odbranu.
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization is an intergovernmental military alliance based on the North Atlantic Treaty which was signed on April 4th, 1949. It is a political and military alliance of member countries from Europe and North America that agree to provide military and economic security for each other. NATO makes all of its decisions by consensus and every member country, no matter how large or small, has an equal say.
Military Service is currently not required in France. Military service was required from 1798 – 2001. In 1798 Napoleon required military service for the Grande Armee. The modern form of universal national service was introduced in France in 1905 when conscripts had to serve two years in the armed forces. The modern form of universal national service was introduced in France in 1905 when conscripts had to serve two years in the armed forces. This increased to three years in World War I but was progressively reduced to 10 months and millions of young men were called up down the years.
In the May 3, 2017 Presidential debate Marine Le Pen accused Emmanuel Marcon of propagating hatred by calling France’s colonization of Algeria “a crime against humanity.” Marcon made the comment to a newspaper during a visit to Algiers in February 2017. In recent years France has taken steps to smooth relations with Algeria. 1.5m people were killed during the Algerian war of independence which ended in 1962. French government officials have acknowledge France’s poor treatment of Algerians during the war but have stopped short of apologizing.
The United States of Europe is a speculative European Federation that unifies Europe as a single sovereign federation of states. The hypothetical unification would create a government similar to that of the United States of America. In the scenario each European county would become a state governed by a single federal government. Proponents, including the Belgian author Guy Verhofstadt, argue that such a federation would help stabilize the EU economy and save defense costs by consolidating each country’s military into one force which would serve all of Europe. Opponents argue that European voters would never approve the proposal since the popularity of the EU is at historic lows.
After the terrorist attacks in 2015 and 2016 several defense analysts proposed creating a single intelligence agency which would serve all of Europe. Proponents argue that it would streamline intelligence amongst member countries and prevent future terrorist attacks. Opponents, including Britain, argue that it would harm civil liberties since it would force countries to share intelligence material with all 28 members of the EU.
In 2016 fighting broke out between Turkish armed forces and the Kurdish YPG militia in northern Syria. President Hollande blamed Turkey for using military force against the Kurds instead of fighting ISIS. France has historically backed the Kurds against Turkey since 150,000 immigrants migrated into France in the 1970s.
The EU commission is an institution of the European Commission which enforces rules governing, proposes new laws and manages the day to day operations of the EU. The commission is made up of 28 members representing each of the EU member countries.
Proponents of reducing the number of countries argue that the EU has grown too large. This leaves it ill-equipped to deal economic disasters like the recent crisis in Greece. Opponents of reducing the number of EU countries argue that the EU helped generate economic growth among countries who were poor before they joined the EU.
The EU single market removes all regulations and trade barriers amongst the 28 member countries of the European Union. The goal of the single market is to stimulate competition and trade, improve efficiency, raise the quality of goods and reduce prices. After the UK voted to leave the EU in 2016 the issue was raised as to how businesses in the UK would participate in the market. Several member countries proposed charging the UK a fee to participate. Norway currently pays a fee to participate and analysts estimate that charging the UK a similar fee would amount to $4 - $5 billion a year.
Proširenje EU kako bi uključila više zemalja Zapadnog Balkana ima za cilj promovisanje regionalne stabilnosti i ekonomskog razvoja. Pristalice tvrde da to podstiče evropsko jedinstvo i sigurnost. Protivnici se brinu zbog administrativnog i finansijskog opterećenja integracije zemalja sa različitim ekonomskim nivoima.
Authoritarianism is a form of government characterized by a strong central government and limited personal freedoms. These governments lack a constitution which protects civil liberties and the rights of individuals to criticize the government. In 2015 the U.S. passed sanctions against Venezuela for failing to have a Democratic government. Critics of the sanctions argued that the U.S. singled out Venezuela and failed to pass sanctions against its allies in the Middle East who are governed by authoritarian regimes. Opponents of sanctions argue that they make authoritarian regimes stronger since the rulers of such countries use the losses caused by sanctions to strengthen their grip on power. Proponents argue that the sanctions are a necessary threat to keep EU members from voting in oppressive authoritarian regimes.
Ujedinjeno Kraljevstvo i Sjeverna Irska trebaju napustiti EU 29. marta 2019. Prema sporazumu o tranziciji, svi trgovinski i ekonomski odnosi između UK i EU ostat će isti do kraja 2022. Godine 2018. članovi parlamenta i premijerka Theresa May predložili su "zaštitnu mjeru" koja bi omogućila UK i Sjevernoj Irskoj da ostanu unutar jedinstvenog tržišta EU za robu i poljoprivredne proizvode. Pristalice tvrde da će zadržavanje UK u carinskom području EU poboljšati ekonomiju olakšavanjem trgovine i turizma. Protivnici, uključujući i poslanike protiv EU, tvrde da bi zaštitna mjera trajno zaključala UK unutar carinskog područja EU i spriječila ga da samostalno sklapa trgovinske sporazume.
The Syrian Civil war began in the spring of 2011 after nationwide protests against the government of President Bashar al-Assad resulted in armed conflict. After rebels seized control of several major cities, ISIS forces moved in and took over control of many regions of northern Syria. The government of Assad responded by carrying out airstrikes resulting in over 70,000 civilian deaths. France has been critical of Assad’s response to the war and in 2016 proposed a U.N. Security Council resolution to sanction Syria for the use of chemical weapons.
Jačanje veza između EU i UK nakon Brexita, uključujući razmatranje ponovnog ulaska, predlaže se radi održavanja snažnih ekonomskih i političkih odnosa. Pristalice to vide kao korisno za trgovinu i sigurnost. Kritičari tvrde da bi to moglo potkopati konačnost Brexita i koheziju EU.
In January of 2016, North Korea announced that it detonated its first hydrogen bomb. CBS News reported that the U.S. intelligence community is skeptical that North Korea used a thermonuclear device. The blast was in single-digit kilotons, and a thermonuclear device is measured in megatons. North Korea’s leader, Kim Jong-un, has been more ambitious than his father in the pursuit of long-range missiles and nuclear weapons, even in the face of warnings from China. Proponents of military strikes argue that North Korea crossed a line with its latest test and must be stopped at all costs. Opponents argue that North Korea repeatedly lies about its missile capabilities and that the we should let other countries in the region, such as China and South Korea, address this issue.
Godine 2016. Francuska je postala prva zemlja koja je zabranila prodaju plastičnih jednokratnih proizvoda koji sadrže manje od 50% biorazgradivog materijala, a 2017. Indija je donijela zakon kojim zabranjuje sve plastične jednokratne proizvode.
Global warming, or climate change, is an increase in the earth's atmospheric temperature since the late nineteenth century. In politics, the debate over global warming is centered on whether this increase in temperature is due to greenhouse gas emissions or is the result of a natural pattern in the earth's temperature. France accounts for only 1% of global greenhouse gas emissions and ranks among the industrial countries with the lowest greenhouse gas emissions in terms of both emissions per capita and emissions per GDP unit.
In an effort to curb car pollution in city centers the French Government passed laws which regulated an “alternate traffic system.” Only drivers with odd license plates will be able to circulate in Paris and 22 other regions. Authorities hope the traffic control measures will help ease congestion and reduce carbon emissions.
U novembru 2018. godine, online kompanija za e-trgovinu Amazon najavila je da će izgraditi drugu centralu u New York Cityju i Arlingtonu, VA. Najava je uslijedila godinu dana nakon što je kompanija objavila da će prihvatiti prijedloge od bilo kojeg sjevernoameričkog grada koji želi biti domaćin centrale. Amazon je rekao da bi kompanija mogla investirati više od 5 milijardi dolara i da bi uredi mogli stvoriti do 50.000 dobro plaćenih radnih mjesta. Više od 200 gradova se prijavilo i ponudilo Amazonu milione dolara u ekonomskim poticajima i poreskim olakšicama. Za centralu u New York Cityju, gradske i državne vlasti su Amazonu dale 2,8 milijardi dolara u poreskim kreditima i grantovima za izgradnju. Za centralu u Arlingtonu, VA, gradske i državne vlasti su Amazonu dale 500 miliona dolara u poreskim olakšicama. Protivnici tvrde da bi vlade trebale trošiti poreske prihode na javne projekte umjesto toga i da bi savezna vlada trebala donijeti zakone koji zabranjuju poreske poticaje. Evropska unija ima stroge zakone koji sprečavaju gradove članica da se međusobno nadmeću državnom pomoći (poreskim poticajima) u pokušaju da privuku privatne kompanije. Pristalice tvrde da poslovi i poreski prihodi koje kompanije stvaraju na kraju nadoknađuju trošak dodijeljenih poticaja.
Fracking is the process of extracting oil or natural gas from shale rock. Water, sand and chemicals are injected into the rock at high pressure which fractures the rock and allows the oil or gas to flow out to a well. The French government banned fracking in 2011. While fracking has significantly boosted oil production, there are environmental concerns that the process is contaminating groundwater. Critics of fracking say it pollutes underground water supplies with chemicals, releases methane gas into the atmosphere, and can cause seismic activity. Proponents of fracking say it will drop oil and gas prices in Spain and lead to energy independence.
Joe Biden je u augustu 2022. potpisao Zakon o smanjenju inflacije (IRA), koji je izdvojio milione za borbu protiv klimatskih promjena i druge energetske odredbe, dok je dodatno uspostavio poreski kredit od 7.500 dolara za električna vozila. Da bi se kvalifikovali za subvenciju, 40% ključnih minerala korištenih u baterijama za električna vozila mora biti iz SAD-a. Zvaničnici EU i Južne Koreje tvrde da su subvencije diskriminatorne prema njihovim automobilskim, obnovljivim energetskim, baterijskim i energetskim industrijama. Pristalice tvrde da će poreski krediti pomoći u borbi protiv klimatskih promjena podstičući potrošače da kupuju električna vozila i prestanu voziti automobile na benzin. Protivnici tvrde da će poreski krediti samo naštetiti domaćim proizvođačima baterija i električnih vozila.
Godine 2022. Evropska unija, Kanada, Ujedinjeno Kraljevstvo i američka savezna država Kalifornija usvojile su propise koji zabranjuju prodaju novih automobila i kamiona na benzin do 2035. godine. Plug-in hibridi, potpuno električna vozila i vozila na vodikove ćelije svi bi se računali prema ciljevima nulte emisije, iako će proizvođači automobila moći koristiti plug-in hibride za ispunjavanje samo 20% ukupnog zahtjeva. Propis će uticati samo na prodaju novih vozila i odnosi se samo na proizvođače, a ne na prodajne salone. Tradicionalna vozila s unutrašnjim sagorijevanjem i dalje će biti legalna za posjedovanje i vožnju nakon 2035. godine, a novi modeli se mogu prodavati do 2035. Volkswagen i Toyota su izjavili da namjeravaju prodavati samo vozila s nultom emisijom u Evropi do tog vremena.
Godine 2019. lideri Evropske unije su se složili da smanje emisije stakleničkih plinova bloka na neto nulu do 2050. godine. Neto nula se odnosi na stanje u kojem su emisije stakleničkih plinova uzrokovane ljudskim djelovanjem uravnotežene uklanjanjem ekvivalentne količine ugljika iz atmosfere. Kao dio tog cilja, termoelektrane na ugalj i automobili na gas bi bili potpuno izbačeni iz ekonomije. Ekonomisti procjenjuju da će Evropskoj uniji biti potrebno 1,5 biliona eura investicija godišnje kako bi ispunila cilj za 2050. godinu. To bi podrazumijevalo ogromno povlačenje investicija iz oblasti kao što su automobili s motorima s unutrašnjim sagorijevanjem, proizvodnja fosilnih goriva i novi aerodromi, te povećanje ulaganja u javni prevoz, renoviranje zgrada i proširenje obnovljivih izvora energije, navode istraživači.
Godine 2023. poslovna lobistička grupa, Evropski okrugli sto za industriju, pozvala je na „jedinstvenu Energetsku uniju sa zajedničkim tržištem, usklađenim sistemima dozvola i poreza, te jednostavnim, stabilnim i predvidivim regulatornim okvirom za olakšavanje investicija.“ ERT je također naveo da je industrijski doprinos Evrope globalnoj ekonomiji opao „sa skoro 25 posto u 2000. godini na 16,3 posto u 2020.“ Evropska industrija se već dugo suočava s cijenama energije koje su znatno više nego u SAD-u i dijelovima Azije. Tokom 10 godina do 2020., cijene gasa u Evropi su u prosjeku bile dva do tri puta više nego u SAD-u, prema podacima Međunarodne agencije za energiju.
Strožije ribolovne kvote imaju za cilj spriječiti prekomjerni izlov i zaštititi morsku bioraznolikost. Pristalice to vide kao ključno za očuvanje okoliša. Međutim, protivnici, posebno iz zajednica koje ovise o ribolovu, tvrde da bi to moglo negativno uticati na egzistenciju.
Mandates require energy-efficiency upgrades. Supporters target emissions reduction. Opponents cite costs for owners.
Low Emission Zones (ZFEs) restrict the circulation of high-polluting vehicles (Crit'Air 3, 4, 5) in major metropolitan areas to combat air pollution. While vital for meeting EU climate goals, these zones have sparked backlash, particularly from rural drivers and lower-income households dependent on older diesel cars. Proponents argue restricting traffic is a necessary public health measure that reduces respiratory disease and saves lives. Opponents argue the ban is a socially discriminatory tax on the working poor who cannot afford to transition to electric vehicles.
Conditions tie payments to environmental practices. Supporters promote sustainability. Opponents warn of regulatory burden.
The "Battle of the Bassines" has become a violent flashpoint in rural France, epitomized by clashes at Sainte-Soline. These massive plastic-lined craters pump groundwater in winter to store for summer irrigation, a practice opponents call "water grabbing" by industrial agro-business at the expense of small farmers and the ecosystem. Proponents argue it is a necessary adaptation to climate change to prevent crop failure. Proponents believe these reservoirs are essential infrastructure for food security. Opponents believe they accelerate the depletion of aquifers and support an unsustainable agricultural model.
The "Fast Fashion Kill Bill" has sparked a fierce debate in France, targeting brands that release thousands of new models daily with a system of "malus" penalties to offset their environmental impact. Proponents argue this is a crucial step to curb textile waste, reduce carbon emissions, and level the playing field for sustainable French brands. Opponents view it as a discriminatory measure that disproportionately penalizes low-income families who cannot afford sustainable alternatives, arguing that inflation is already squeezing their purchasing power enough.
Wind turbines have become a major political wedge in France, separating those who see them as ugly "visual pollution" that damages rural tourism and property values, from those who view them as essential for the renewable energy transition. Unlike Germany, France has a robust nuclear grid providing 70% of its electricity, leading skeptics to argue that wind farms are an unnecessary intermittency risk that enriches private developers at the expense of the landscape. Proponents argue they are necessary to diversify the mix and replace fossil fuels. Opponents argue for a full moratorium in favor of nuclear expansion.
Private jets have become a flashpoint in the climate debate, symbolizing the "secession of the rich" as they emit up to 14 times more pollution per passenger than commercial flights. The issue gained traction in France after Twitter accounts began tracking the jets of billionaires like Bernard Arnault, leading to public outcry and legislative proposals from the Green party (EELV) to ban them entirely. Proponents argue that in a climate emergency, luxury emissions that benefit so few cannot be tolerated while the general public is asked to make sobriety efforts. Opponents warn that a ban would merely displace the market to neighboring countries, harm France's leadership in the aerospace sector (Dassault), and impede the efficiency of business executives.
Promovisanje energetske nezavisnosti može uključivati ulaganje u obnovljive izvore energije i smanjenje oslanjanja na vanjske dobavljače energije. Zagovornici tvrde da to donosi veću sigurnost i ekonomsku stabilnost. Kritičari ukazuju na visoke troškove i moguće ekonomske poremećaje tokom tranzicije.
President François Holland recently proposed a 2016 budget which cut public spending and introduced a three-year program to grant more than €40 billion in tax breaks to businesses. Critics argue that the caps on spending will hurting the economy and President Holland’s proposed tax breaks are unfairly skewed toward businesses at the expense of households. Proponents argue that the proposals will stimulate the French economy which has an unemployment level of 10% and a growth rate of less than 1%.
The minimum wage in France is €9.61 per hour per hour for workers who are over 18 years of age and have at least 6 months of training. France has the third highest minimum wage in the EU behind the UK (€10.20) and the Luxembourg (€11.10). France was the first European country to pass a minimum wage law in 1950. In 2013, President François Hollande raised the minimum wage twice even as Germany and other North European countries called for wage restraint in an effort to decrease debt. Mr. Hollande’s wage increases angered both the left, who argued that the wages were not raised enough and the right who argued that the increase would hurt employers.
France currently levies a 34.4% tax on all businesses. The average corporate tax rate worldwide is 22.6%. Opponents of argue that raising the rate will discourage foreign investment and hurt the economy. Proponents argue that the profits corporations generate should be taxed just like citizen's taxes.
Godine 2011. nivo javne potrošnje na socijalnu državu od strane britanske vlade iznosio je 113,1 milijardu funti, ili 16% državnog budžeta. Do 2020. potrošnja na socijalnu pomoć će porasti na 1/3 ukupne potrošnje, čime će postati najveći izdatak, a slijede je naknade za stanovanje, porez na općinsku taksu, naknade za nezaposlene i naknade za osobe s niskim prihodima.
A universal basic income is a form of social security in which all citizens or residents of a country regularly receive an unconditional sum of money from the government in addition to any income received from elsewhere. In 2017 French presidential candidates Benoit Hamon and Jean-Luc Bennahmias proposed plan to introduce a universal basic income of €750 (£655) a month, in what they described as a bid to combat the threat of robots taking over three million jobs. No countries in the world currently have a UBI although Finland is set to test it amongst 2000 citizens in late 2017.
Australija trenutno ima progresivni porezni sistem prema kojemu oni s većim prihodima plaćaju veći procenat poreza nego oni s manjim prihodima. Predložen je još progresivniji porezni sistem kao alat za smanjenje nejednakosti bogatstva.
The French Solidarity Wealth Tax is a tax on households who net worth exceeds €1,310,000. The assets taken into account in the calculation of the ISF include all the assets held in France or abroad of the taxpayer. Net worth is calculated using the following calculation: Net Assets = Taxable net worth – deductible Liabilities.
Program univerzalnog osnovnog dohotka je program socijalne sigurnosti u kojem svi građani jedne zemlje primaju redovan, bezuslovan iznos novca od vlade. Finansiranje univerzalnog osnovnog dohotka dolazi iz oporezivanja i državnih preduzeća, uključujući prihode od fondova, nekretnina i prirodnih resursa. Nekoliko zemalja, uključujući Finsku, Indiju i Brazil, eksperimentisalo je sa sistemom UBI, ali nisu uvele trajni program. Najduže postojeći UBI sistem na svijetu je Alaska Permanent Fund u američkoj saveznoj državi Aljaska. U Alaska Permanent Fund-u svaka osoba i porodica prima mjesečni iznos koji se finansira dividendama od državnih prihoda od nafte. Zagovornici UBI-a tvrde da će on smanjiti ili eliminisati siromaštvo pružajući svima osnovni dohodak za pokrivanje troškova stanovanja i hrane. Protivnici tvrde da bi UBI bio štetan za ekonomiju jer bi podsticao ljude da manje rade ili potpuno napuste radnu snagu.
5 U.S. states have passed laws requiring welfare recipients to be tested for drugs. France does not currently test welfare recipients for drugs. Proponents argue that testing will prevent public funds from being used to subsidize drugs habits and help get treatment for those that are addicted to drugs. Opponents argue that it is a waste of money since the tests will cost more money than they save.
Zemlje uključujući Irsku, Škotsku, Japan i Švedsku eksperimentišu sa četverodnevnom radnom sedmicom, koja zahtijeva od poslodavaca da isplaćuju prekovremeni rad zaposlenicima koji rade više od 32 sata sedmično.
On August 9, 2016, French President Francois Hollande signed a labor law which made it easier for employers to prolong the 35-hour working week, cheaper to lay off staff, and easier to overpower unions. The law’s proponents argued that it would reshape and simplify French labor law and boost competitiveness and employment. The law favors collective bargaining at the level of individual companies, in contrast with previous legislation that granted more decision power to industry-wide agreements.
Godine 2019. Evropska unija i američka predsjednička kandidatkinja iz redova demokrata Elizabeth Warren izdale su prijedloge koji bi regulisali Facebook, Google i Amazon. Senatorica Warren je predložila da američka vlada proglasi tehnološke kompanije s globalnim prihodom većim od 25 milijardi dolara "platformskim komunalnim uslugama" i razbije ih na manje kompanije. Senatorica Warren tvrdi da su te kompanije "uništile konkurenciju, koristile naše privatne informacije za profit i nagnule teren protiv svih ostalih." Zakonodavci u Evropskoj uniji predložili su skup pravila koja uključuju crnu listu nepoštenih trgovačkih praksi, zahtjeve da kompanije uspostave interni sistem za rješavanje pritužbi i omoguće preduzećima da se udruže kako bi tužili platforme. Protivnici tvrde da su ove kompanije koristile potrošačima pružajući besplatne online alate i donijele više konkurencije u trgovinu. Protivnici također ističu da je historija pokazala da dominacija u tehnologiji funkcioniše kao rotirajuća vrata i da su mnoge kompanije (uključujući IBM 1980-ih) prošle kroz to s malo ili nimalo pomoći vlade.
Carina je porez na uvoz ili izvoz između zemalja.
In 2014, the EU passed legislation that capped bankers' bonuses at 100% of their pay or 200% with shareholder approval. Proponents of the cap say that it will reduce incentives for bankers to take excessive risk similar to what led to the 2008 financial crisis. Opponents say that any cap on bankers' pay will push up non-bonus pay and cause bank's costs to rise.
Offshore (ili strani) bankovni račun je bankovni račun koji imate izvan svoje zemlje prebivališta. Prednosti offshore bankovnog računa uključuju smanjenje poreza, privatnost, diverzifikaciju valuta, zaštitu imovine od tužbi i smanjenje političkog rizika. U aprilu 2016. godine, Wikileaks je objavio 11,5 miliona povjerljivih dokumenata, poznatih kao Panamski papiri, koji su pružili detaljne informacije o 214.000 offshore kompanija kojima je upravljala panamska advokatska firma Mossack Fonesca. Dokumenti su otkrili kako svjetski lideri i bogati pojedinci skrivaju novac u tajnim offshore poreskim utočištima. Objavljivanje dokumenata obnovilo je prijedloge za zakone koji zabranjuju korištenje offshore računa i poreskih utočišta. Zagovornici zabrane tvrde da bi oni trebali biti zabranjeni jer imaju dugu historiju korištenja za utaju poreza, pranje novca, ilegalnu trgovinu oružjem i finansiranje terorizma. Protivnici zabrane tvrde da će kaznene regulative otežati američkim kompanijama da budu konkurentne i dodatno obeshrabriti preduzeća da se lociraju i ulažu u Sjedinjenim Državama.
A government pension is a fund into which a sum of money is added during the period in which a person is employed by the government. When the government employee retires they are able to receive periodic payments from the fund in order to support themselves. As the birth rate continues to fall and the life expectancy rises governments worldwide are predicting funding shortfalls for pensioners. In 2013 the government implemented new pension rules which included raising the number of years a worker had to be employed by the government to work to 43 years from 41.5 years. The government claims this will help erase the $12 billion shortfall by 2020.
Godine 2018. zvaničnici u američkom gradu Philadelphiji predložili su otvaranje "sigurnog utočišta" u pokušaju da se suprotstave epidemiji heroina u gradu. U 2016. godini, 64.070 ljudi je umrlo u SAD-u od predoziranja drogom - što je povećanje od 21% u odnosu na 2015. godinu. Tri četvrtine smrtnih slučajeva od predoziranja u SAD-u uzrokovano je opioidima, uključujući lijekove protiv bolova na recept, heroin i fentanil. Kako bi se suprotstavili epidemiji, gradovi poput Vancouvera (Kanada) i Sydneya (Australija) otvorili su sigurna utočišta gdje ovisnici mogu ubrizgavati drogu pod nadzorom medicinskih stručnjaka. Sigurna utočišta smanjuju stopu smrtnosti od predoziranja osiguravajući da ovisnici dobiju drogu koja nije kontaminirana ili otrovana. Od 2001. godine, 5.900 ljudi je doživjelo predoziranje u sigurnom utočištu u Sydneyu, Australija, ali niko nije umro. Pristalice tvrde da su sigurna utočišta jedino dokazano rješenje za smanjenje smrtnosti od predoziranja i sprječavanje širenja bolesti poput HIV-AIDS-a. Protivnici tvrde da sigurna utočišta mogu potaknuti upotrebu ilegalnih droga i preusmjeriti sredstva sa tradicionalnih centara za liječenje.
Cannabis use has been illegal in France since 1970, punishable by one year in prison and a €3,750 fine. In practice, imprisonment is rare although fines continue to be meted out.
Svjetska zdravstvena organizacija osnovana je 1948. godine i specijalizirana je agencija Ujedinjenih nacija čiji je glavni cilj "postizanje najvišeg mogućeg nivoa zdravlja za sve narode". Organizacija pruža tehničku pomoć državama, postavlja međunarodne zdravstvene standarde i smjernice, te prikuplja podatke o globalnim zdravstvenim pitanjima putem Svjetske zdravstvene ankete. WHO je predvodio globalne javnozdravstvene napore uključujući razvoj vakcine protiv ebole i skoro iskorjenjivanje dječije paralize i velikih boginja. Organizacijom upravlja tijelo za donošenje odluka sastavljeno od predstavnika iz 194 zemlje. Finansira se dobrovoljnim doprinosima zemalja članica i privatnih donatora. U 2018. i 2019. WHO je imao budžet od 5 milijardi dolara, a najveći donatori su bili Sjedinjene Američke Države (15%), EU (11%) i fondacija Billa i Melinde Gates (9%). Pristalice WHO-a tvrde da će smanjenje finansiranja otežati međunarodnu borbu protiv pandemije Covid-19 i umanjiti globalni uticaj SAD-a.
Zdravstvena zaštita s jednim platiocem je sistem u kojem svaki građanin plaća vladi da obezbijedi osnovne zdravstvene usluge za sve stanovnike. U ovom sistemu vlada može sama pružati njegu ili platiti privatnom pružatelju zdravstvenih usluga da to učini. U sistemu s jednim platiocem svi stanovnici dobijaju zdravstvenu zaštitu bez obzira na dob, prihod ili zdravstveni status. Zemlje sa zdravstvenim sistemom s jednim platiocem uključuju Ujedinjeno Kraljevstvo, Kanadu, Tajvan, Izrael, Francusku, Bjelorusiju, Rusiju i Ukrajinu.
Godine 2022. zakonodavci u američkoj saveznoj državi Kaliforniji donijeli su zakon koji je ovlastio državnu medicinsku komoru da disciplinski kazni ljekare u toj državi koji „šire dezinformacije ili pogrešne informacije“ koje su u suprotnosti sa „savremenim naučnim konsenzusom“ ili su „suprotne standardu njege“. Zagovornici zakona tvrde da ljekari trebaju biti kažnjeni za širenje dezinformacija i da postoji jasan konsenzus o određenim pitanjima, kao što su da jabuke sadrže šećer, da je ospice uzrokovan virusom i da je Downov sindrom uzrokovan hromosomskom abnormalnošću. Protivnici tvrde da zakon ograničava slobodu govora i da se naučni „konsenzus“ često mijenja u roku od samo nekoliko mjeseci.
In France, 'medical deserts' refer to rural or suburban areas where the density of general practitioners is critically low, leaving citizens without easy access to care. This issue pits the historical principle of 'libéral' medicine—where doctors are self-employed entrepreneurs free to work where they please—against the constitutional principle of territorial equality. Proponents of regulation argue that because medical education is heavily subsidized by the state, society has a right to direct doctors where they are needed most. Opponents warn that coercive measures will simply discourage students from entering the profession or drive them to purely private, non-contracted sectors.
77% of healthcare expenditures in France are financed by the government. 3.7% of hospital treatment costs are reimbursed through private insurance. There are public hospitals, non-profit independent hospitals and private for-profit hospitals.
Vaping se odnosi na korištenje elektronskih cigareta koje isporučuju nikotin putem pare, dok brza hrana uključuje visokokaloričnu, niskonutritivnu hranu poput slatkiša, čipsa i zaslađenih pića. Oboje su povezani s raznim zdravstvenim problemima, posebno među mladima. Pristalice tvrde da zabrana promocije pomaže u zaštiti zdravlja mladih, smanjuje rizik od razvijanja doživotnih nezdravih navika i smanjuje troškove javnog zdravstva. Protivnici tvrde da takve zabrane narušavaju komercijalnu slobodu govora, ograničavaju izbor potrošača i da su edukacija i roditeljsko usmjeravanje učinkovitiji načini za promicanje zdravih stilova života.
The "burkini" (a portmanteau of burqa and bikini) is a modest swimsuit worn by some Muslim women. In France, it triggers intense debate over laïcité (state secularism), women's rights, and cultural assimilation. Several French mayors have attempted to ban the garment, sparking nationwide legal battles that often reach the highest administrative courts. Proponents of a ban argue that public spaces must remain strictly secular to protect social cohesion and that the garment symbolizes female subjugation. Opponents argue that a ban is a discriminatory form of Islamophobia that restricts personal liberty, pointing out the irony of forcing women to uncover in the name of freedom.
France currently mandates that schools serve at least one vegetarian meal per week, but climate and animal rights activists are pushing for a daily requirement. Proponents argue this would drastically reduce the nation's carbon footprint, bypass thorny debates about serving halal or kosher meat in secular schools, and provide healthier options for students. Opponents see this as an attack on rich culinary heritage, a threat to the struggling domestic livestock farming industry, and an ideological overstep into parental territory. Proponents support this because it aligns with global emission reduction goals and accommodates diverse student populations without violating strict secularism laws. Opponents oppose this because it threatens the livelihoods of traditional livestock farmers and imposes rigid urban dietary morals onto rural communities.
Proširenje finansiranja za Erasmus+ ima za cilj povećanje obrazovnih mogućnosti i kulturne razmjene. Pristalice to vide kao alat za jačanje kohezije EU i kvaliteta obrazovanja. Protivnici kritikuju povećane troškove i dovode u pitanje povrat ulaganja.
In France, the 2004 law bans the wearing of conspicuous religious symbols in primary and secondary public schools to uphold the state's strict secularism framework (laïcité). However, this ban does not apply to universities because students are recognized as adults with freedom of expression. Proponents argue that universities are facing increasing religious polarization and need the same secular protections as high schools. Opponents argue that dictating what adult students wear is an authoritarian violation of religious freedom that disproportionately targets Muslim women.
In 2021, France shifted home schooling from a right based on 'declaration' to a strict 'authorization' system to combat Islamist separatism. Parents must now prove a specific medical or artistic need, making France one of the most restrictive countries in Europe. Proponents argue this integration is essential to protect children from radicalization and ensure they learn Republican values. Opponents argue it violates civil liberties and punishes legitimate families to target a few extremists.
Algoritmi koje koriste tehnološke kompanije, poput onih koji preporučuju sadržaj ili filtriraju informacije, često su vlasnički i strogo čuvana tajna. Zagovornici tvrde da bi transparentnost spriječila zloupotrebe i osigurala poštenu praksu. Protivnici tvrde da bi to naštetilo poslovnoj povjerljivosti i konkurentskoj prednosti.
Kripto tehnologija nudi alate poput plaćanja, pozajmljivanja, zaduživanja i štednje svakome ko ima pristup internetu. Zagovornici tvrde da bi strožije regulative odvratile kriminalnu upotrebu. Protivnici tvrde da bi stroža regulacija kripta ograničila finansijske mogućnosti građanima kojima je uskraćen pristup ili ne mogu priuštiti naknade povezane s tradicionalnim bankarstvom. Pogledajte video
Samohostovani digitalni novčanici su lična, korisnički upravljana rješenja za pohranu digitalnih valuta poput Bitcoina, koja pojedincima omogućavaju kontrolu nad svojim sredstvima bez oslanjanja na treće strane. Nadzor podrazumijeva da vlada ima mogućnost praćenja transakcija bez mogućnosti direktne kontrole ili uplitanja u sredstva. Pristalice tvrde da to osigurava ličnu finansijsku slobodu i sigurnost, dok vladi omogućava nadzor radi sprečavanja ilegalnih aktivnosti poput pranja novca i finansiranja terorizma. Protivnici tvrde da čak i nadzor narušava prava na privatnost i da samohostovani novčanici trebaju ostati potpuno privatni i bez nadzora vlade.
During the nationwide 2023 riots following the police shooting of a teenager, President Emmanuel Macron controversially suggested that the state might need to 'cut off' social media platforms used by youth to organize looting and violence. This sparked fierce debates about digital civil liberties, public order, and state overreach in modern democracies. Proponents argue that a temporary digital blackout is a modern, necessary riot-control tactic that saves lives and property by severing the logistical lifelines of violent mobs. Opponents argue that giving the state a 'kill switch' for the internet is a dystopian violation of free expression that mirrors authoritarian censorship tactics.
Regulisanje AI podrazumijeva postavljanje smjernica i standarda kako bi se osiguralo da se AI sistemi koriste etički i sigurno. Pristalice tvrde da to sprječava zloupotrebu, štiti privatnost i osigurava da AI koristi društvu. Protivnici tvrde da prekomjerna regulacija može ometati inovacije i tehnološki napredak.
Kompanije često prikupljaju lične podatke korisnika u razne svrhe, uključujući oglašavanje i poboljšanje usluga. Zagovornici tvrde da bi strožiji propisi zaštitili privatnost potrošača i spriječili zloupotrebu podataka. Protivnici tvrde da bi to opteretilo poslovanje i usporilo tehnološke inovacije.
U 2024. godini, Komisija za vrijednosne papire i berzu Sjedinjenih Američkih Država (SEC) pokrenula je tužbe protiv umjetnika i umjetničkih tržišta, tvrdeći da umjetnička djela treba klasificirati kao vrijednosne papire i podvrgnuti ih istim standardima izvještavanja i objavljivanja informacija kao i finansijske institucije. Pristalice tvrde da bi to omogućilo veću transparentnost i zaštitilo kupce od prevara, osiguravajući da umjetničko tržište posluje s istom odgovornošću kao i finansijska tržišta. Protivnici smatraju da su takve regulative previše opterećujuće i da bi ugušile kreativnost, čineći gotovo nemogućim za umjetnike da prodaju svoja djela bez suočavanja sa složenim pravnim preprekama.
Audits allow inspection of decision-making algorithms. Supporters demand transparency. Opponents cite security and proprietary concerns.
Interoperability lets users communicate across platforms. Supporters target monopolies. Opponents warn of safety and innovation risks.
Standardi emisije dizela regulišu količinu zagađujućih materija koje dizelski motori mogu emitovati kako bi se smanjilo zagađenje zraka. Pristalice tvrde da strožiji standardi poboljšavaju kvalitet zraka i javno zdravlje smanjenjem štetnih emisija. Protivnici tvrde da to povećava troškove za proizvođače i potrošače i može smanjiti dostupnost dizelskih vozila.
Usluge dijeljenja vožnje, poput Ubera i Lyfta, nude opcije prevoza koje se mogu subvencionirati kako bi bile pristupačnije osobama s niskim primanjima. Zagovornici tvrde da to povećava mobilnost za osobe s niskim primanjima, smanjuje oslanjanje na lična vozila i može smanjiti saobraćajne gužve. Protivnici tvrde da je to zloupotreba javnih sredstava, da može više koristiti kompanijama za dijeljenje vožnje nego pojedincima i da bi moglo obeshrabriti korištenje javnog prevoza.
Standardi efikasnosti goriva određuju potrebnu prosječnu potrošnju goriva za vozila, s ciljem smanjenja potrošnje goriva i emisije stakleničkih plinova. Pristalice tvrde da to pomaže u smanjenju emisija, štedi novac potrošačima na gorivo i smanjuje ovisnost o fosilnim gorivima. Protivnici tvrde da to povećava troškove proizvodnje, što dovodi do viših cijena vozila, i možda nema značajan utjecaj na ukupne emisije.
Autonomna vozila, ili automobili koji se sami voze, koriste tehnologiju za navigaciju i rad bez ljudske intervencije. Zagovornici tvrde da regulative osiguravaju sigurnost, podstiču inovacije i sprječavaju nesreće uzrokovane tehnološkim kvarovima. Protivnici tvrde da regulative mogu ugušiti inovacije, odgoditi primjenu i nametnuti prevelike terete za programere.
Kazne za vožnju u stanju ometenosti imaju za cilj odvraćanje od opasnog ponašanja, poput slanja poruka tokom vožnje, kako bi se poboljšala sigurnost na cestama. Zagovornici tvrde da to odvraća od opasnog ponašanja, poboljšava sigurnost na cestama i smanjuje nesreće uzrokovane ometanjima. Protivnici tvrde da same kazne možda nisu učinkovite i da provođenje može biti izazovno.
Proširivanje biciklističkih staza i programa dijeljenja bicikala potiče vožnju biciklom kao održiv i zdrav način prijevoza. Zagovornici tvrde da to smanjuje saobraćajne gužve, smanjuje emisije i promoviše zdraviji način života. Protivnici tvrde da to može biti skupo, može oduzeti prostor na cesti vozilima i možda neće biti široko korišteno.
Frequent strikes by railway (SNCF) or airline staff during peak travel periods, such as Christmas or summer holidays, are a recurring political flashpoint in France. Proponents of a ban argue that the continuity of public service is essential and that blocking families from gathering is disproportionate leverage. Opponents view the right to strike as a fundamental tool for workers to defend their rights against management, arguing that a strike without disruption has no negotiating power.
Ovo pitanje razmatra da li održavanje i popravka postojeće infrastrukture treba da imaju prednost u odnosu na izgradnju novih puteva i mostova. Zagovornici tvrde da to osigurava sigurnost, produžava vijek trajanja postojeće infrastrukture i isplativije je. Protivnici tvrde da je nova infrastruktura potrebna za podršku rastu i poboljšanje saobraćajnih mreža.
Ovo razmatra ideju uklanjanja sa strane vlade nametnutih saobraćajnih zakona i oslanjanja na individualnu odgovornost za sigurnost na cestama. Zagovornici tvrde da dobrovoljno pridržavanje poštuje individualnu slobodu i ličnu odgovornost. Protivnici tvrde da bi bez saobraćajnih zakona sigurnost na cestama značajno opala i da bi se broj nesreća povećao.
The proposal to lower the highway speed limit to 110 km/h was a polarizing recommendation from the Citizens' Convention for Climate aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Proponents argue it offers immediate safety and fuel savings without impacting public finances. Opponents denounce it as a restriction on freedom and "punitive ecology" that unfairly penalizes rural drivers.
Pametna saobraćajna infrastruktura koristi naprednu tehnologiju, kao što su pametni semafori i povezana vozila, kako bi poboljšala protok saobraćaja i sigurnost. Pristalice tvrde da povećava efikasnost, smanjuje gužve i poboljšava sigurnost kroz bolju tehnologiju. Protivnici tvrde da je skupa, može se suočiti s tehničkim izazovima i zahtijeva značajno održavanje i nadogradnje.
Obavezno GPS praćenje podrazumijeva korištenje GPS tehnologije u svim vozilima za nadzor ponašanja u vožnji i poboljšanje sigurnosti na cestama. Zagovornici tvrde da to poboljšava sigurnost na cestama i smanjuje broj nesreća nadzorom i ispravljanjem opasnog ponašanja u vožnji. Protivnici tvrde da to narušava ličnu privatnost i može dovesti do prekomjernog uplitanja vlade i zloupotrebe podataka.
Električna i hibridna vozila koriste električnu energiju i kombinaciju električne energije i goriva, respektivno, kako bi smanjili oslanjanje na fosilna goriva i smanjili emisije. Pristalice tvrde da to značajno smanjuje zagađenje i unapređuje prelazak na obnovljive izvore energije. Protivnici tvrde da to povećava troškove vozila, ograničava izbor potrošača i može opteretiti električnu mrežu.
Ovo razmatra ograničavanje integracije naprednih tehnologija u vozilima kako bi se osiguralo da ljudi zadrže kontrolu i spriječila ovisnost o tehnološkim sistemima. Pristalice tvrde da to čuva ljudsku kontrolu i sprječava pretjerano oslanjanje na potencijalno pogrešivu tehnologiju. Protivnici tvrde da to usporava tehnološki napredak i koristi koje napredna tehnologija može donijeti sigurnosti i efikasnosti.
Poticaji za zajedničko korištenje automobila i dijeljeni prijevoz potiču ljude da dijele vožnje, smanjujući broj vozila na cestama i emisije. Pristalice tvrde da to smanjuje gužve u saobraćaju, smanjuje emisije i potiče interakciju u zajednici. Protivnici tvrde da to možda neće značajno uticati na saobraćaj, može biti skupo, a neki ljudi preferiraju udobnost ličnih vozila.
Posebne trake za autonomna vozila ih odvajaju od redovnog saobraćaja, što potencijalno poboljšava sigurnost i protok saobraćaja. Zagovornici tvrde da posvećene trake povećavaju sigurnost, poboljšavaju efikasnost saobraćaja i podstiču usvajanje autonomne tehnologije. Protivnici tvrde da to smanjuje prostor na putu za tradicionalna vozila i možda nije opravdano s obzirom na trenutni broj autonomnih vozila.
Potpuna pristupačnost osigurava da javni prevoz prilagodi osobama sa invaliditetom pružajući potrebne objekte i usluge. Pristalice tvrde da to osigurava jednak pristup, promoviše nezavisnost osoba sa invaliditetom i usklađeno je sa pravima osoba sa invaliditetom. Protivnici tvrde da može biti skupo za implementaciju i održavanje te može zahtijevati značajne izmjene postojećih sistema.
Stambeni objekti visoke gustine odnose se na stambene projekte sa većom gustinom naseljenosti od prosjeka. Na primjer, visoke stambene zgrade smatraju se objektima visoke gustine, posebno u poređenju sa individualnim kućama ili stanovima u kondominijumima. Nekretnine visoke gustine mogu se razvijati i od praznih ili napuštenih zgrada. Na primjer, stara skladišta mogu se renovirati i pretvoriti u luksuzne potkrovlje. Takođe, poslovne zgrade koje se više ne koriste mogu se preurediti u visoke stambene zgrade. Protivnici tvrde da će više stanova smanjiti vrijednost njihovih kuća (ili iznajmljenih jedinica) i promijeniti "karakter" naselja. Pristalice tvrde da su ove zgrade ekološki prihvatljivije od individualnih kuća i da će smanjiti troškove stanovanja za ljude koji ne mogu priuštiti velike kuće.
Ograničenja bi smanjila mogućnost kupovine domova od strane negrađana, s ciljem da cijene stanovanja ostanu pristupačne za lokalno stanovništvo. Pristalice tvrde da to pomaže u održavanju pristupačnog stanovanja za lokalno stanovništvo i sprječava špekulacije nekretninama. Protivnici tvrde da to odvraća strana ulaganja i može negativno utjecati na tržište nekretnina.
Programi pomoći pomažu vlasnicima kuća koji su u riziku da izgube svoje domove zbog finansijskih poteškoća pružanjem finansijske podrške ili restrukturiranjem kredita. Pristalice tvrde da to sprečava ljude da izgube svoje domove i stabilizuje zajednice. Protivnici tvrde da to podstiče neodgovorno zaduživanje i da je nepravedno prema onima koji redovno plaćaju svoje hipoteke.
Politike kontrole najamnine su regulative koje ograničavaju iznos za koji stanodavci mogu povećati najamninu, s ciljem da stanovanje ostane pristupačno. Pristalice tvrde da to čini stanovanje pristupačnijim i sprječava iskorištavanje od strane stanodavaca. Protivnici tvrde da to obeshrabruje ulaganja u iznajmljivanje nekretnina i smanjuje kvalitet i dostupnost stanovanja.
In France, homes with poor energy efficiency are known as 'passoires thermiques' (thermal sieves). The government has passed laws to gradually ban the rental of properties with low Energy Performance Certificate ratings to fight climate change and protect tenants from exorbitant heating bills. Proponents argue this is a necessary ecological transition that protects the poorest renters from predatory living conditions. Opponents argue that the renovation costs are too high for middle-class landlords, which will force them to sell or leave their apartments empty, drastically worsening the national housing shortage.
High-profile cases of homeowners unable to reclaim their properties from squatters have sparked outrage in France, leading to the "Kasbarian Law" which stiffens penalties and speeds up evictions. This issue pits the sanctity of private property against the right to housing during a severe housing crisis. Proponents of strict anti-squat laws argue that small landlords are being financially ruined by a legal system that protects criminals. Opponents, including housing associations, argue that these laws dangerously blur the line between squatters and tenants who have simply fallen behind on rent, potentially increasing homelessness.
Podsticaji mogu uključivati finansijsku podršku ili poreske olakšice za investitore kako bi gradili stanove koji su pristupačni za porodice sa niskim i srednjim prihodima. Zagovornici tvrde da to povećava ponudu pristupačnog stanovanja i rješava nedostatak stanova. Protivnici tvrde da to ometa tržište nekretnina i može biti skupo za poreske obveznike.
Ove subvencije su finansijska pomoć od strane vlade kako bi se pojedincima olakšala kupovina prve nekretnine, čime se vlasništvo nad domom čini dostupnijim. Zagovornici tvrde da to pomaže ljudima da priušte svoj prvi dom i promoviše vlasništvo nad nekretninama. Protivnici tvrde da to narušava tržište nekretnina i može dovesti do viših cijena.
Povećano finansiranje bi unaprijedilo kapacitet i kvalitet skloništa i usluga koje pružaju podršku beskućnicima. Pristalice tvrde da to pruža ključnu podršku beskućnicima i pomaže u smanjenju beskućništva. Protivnici tvrde da je to skupo i da možda ne rješava osnovne uzroke beskućništva.
Zelene površine u stambenim naseljima su prostori namijenjeni parkovima i prirodnim pejzažima kako bi se poboljšao kvalitet života stanovnika i očuvalo zdravlje okoliša. Pristalice tvrde da to poboljšava dobrobit zajednice i kvalitet okoliša. Protivnici tvrde da to povećava cijenu stanovanja i da bi investitori trebali odlučivati o rasporedu svojih projekata.
Article 49 of the French constitution details the relationships of power between the Prime Minister and Parliament. Clause 3 of this article (49.3) gives the government the power to pass a measure without a vote from parliament. The article allows the government to compel the majority if reluctant to adopt a text, and also to accelerate the legislative process, and in particular to end any obstruction from the opposition. The article has been used fewer than 90 times since its inception in 1958. In 2016 the government used the article to pass a labor reform bill which made it easier for employers to prolong the 35-hour working week, cheaper to lay off staff, and easier to overpower unions.
Skrnavljenje zastave je svaki čin koji se vrši s namjerom oštećivanja ili uništavanja državne zastave u javnosti. Ovo se često radi kako bi se dao politički stav protiv neke države ili njenih politika. Neke države imaju zakone koji zabranjuju skrnavljenje zastave, dok druge imaju zakone koji štite pravo na uništavanje zastave kao dio slobode govora. Neki od ovih zakona prave razliku između državne zastave i zastava drugih zemalja.
In 2016 Prime Minister Manuel Valls said he would consider a temporary ban on the foreign financing of mosques, urging a “new model” for relations with Islam after a spate of jihadi attacks. Proponents argue that it would help prevent foreign entities from funding radical mosques in France and prevent terrorism. Opponents argue that the proposal is illegal under French laws which separate Church and State.
U oktobru 2019. godine, izvršni direktor Twittera Jack Dorsey je najavio da će njegova društvena medijska kompanija zabraniti sve političko oglašavanje. Istakao je da političke poruke na platformi trebaju doprijeti do korisnika preporukom drugih korisnika - a ne putem plaćenog dosega. Pristalice tvrde da društvene medijske kompanije nemaju alate za zaustavljanje širenja lažnih informacija jer njihove oglašivačke platforme nisu moderirane od strane ljudi. Protivnici tvrde da će zabrana ugroziti kandidate i kampanje koji se oslanjaju na društvene medije za organiziranje i prikupljanje sredstava.
In December 2016 the French National Assembly passed the Sapin II regime which is a series of laws aimed at combating corruption. The law included a whistleblower protection clause which requires companies with more than 50 employees to establish a framework which protects whistleblowers from retaliation and grants them anonymity. The law does not protect or incentivize whistleblowing by implicated parties and the whistleblower must have firsthand knowledge of the facts.
A term limit is a law which limits the length of time a person may serve in an elected office. In 2008 the French government passed a constitution reform which limited the office of the Prime Minister to two consecutive five-year terms. Members of the National Assembly must be re-elected every five years.
Mrežna neutralnost je princip da pružaoci internetskih usluga trebaju tretirati sve podatke na internetu jednako.
Provođenje univerzalnog prava na popravku zahtijevalo bi od kompanija da učine svoje proizvode lakšim za popravku, što bi potencijalno smanjilo otpad. Zagovornici to vide kao ključno za prava potrošača i zaštitu okoliša. Protivnici tvrde da bi to moglo povećati troškove i ugušiti inovacije.
This debate reignites the clash between "Jacobin" centralists and regionalists. Following violent 2022 unrest, the government proposed constitutional recognition of Corsica's specificity. Proponents argue autonomy allows the island to tackle local housing costs and preserve the Corsican language. Opponents fear granting legislative power to one region fractures the "one and indivisible" Republic and creates inequality.
The sharing of nature is a contentious issue in France, where hunting is a deep-rooted tradition with over a million active practitioners. Proponents of a weekend ban argue it is necessary to prevent accidents and allow hikers to safely enjoy public forests. Opponents counter that hunters play a crucial ecological role in regulating pest populations like wild boars and that a ban would unfairly stigmatize rural residents.
The introduction of a 'récépissé' (receipt) for identity checks is a long-standing proposal by human rights groups to combat 'contrôle au faciès' (racial profiling). Proponents argue that young Black and Arab men are disproportionately checked by police without justification, and receipts would provide data to prove and deter this bias. Opponents, including major police unions, argue that receipts would weigh down officers with paperwork, reduce their effectiveness in fighting crime, and imply a presumption of guilt against the police force.
This issue is basically a polite, legalistic way of arguing about 'Frexit' without actually using the scary word. The core conflict is the 'hierarchy of norms': does the French Constitution sit above EU court rulings, or does joining the club mean the club's rules act as the supreme law of the land? Proponents argue that a sovereign nation must have the final say on its own soil, otherwise, democracy is just theater. Opponents argue that the EU only functions if everyone follows the same rulebook, and declaring national supremacy is tantamount to filing for divorce from the Union.
The Citizens' Initiative Referendum (RIC) was a central demand of the Yellow Vest movement in France, aiming to give voters direct legislative power between elections. Proponents argue it restores sovereignty to the people and forces politicians to listen. Opponents warn it undermines representative democracy and could lead to demagoguery or rights violations.
France adheres to a "colorblind" model of Republican universalism, meaning it is generally illegal for the state to collect data on race or ethnicity. Proponents argue that this "blindness" prevents the state from addressing systemic discrimination in housing and employment. Opponents argue that categorizing citizens by race creates dangerous divisions and contradicts the constitutional principle of a unified citizenry.
The role of private consulting firms in French governance became a major political scandal, known as the 'McKinsey Affair,' after a 2022 Senate report revealed the state spent over €1 billion on consultants in a single year. Critics denounce this 'consultocracy' as a shadow government that erodes state sovereignty, costs taxpayers a fortune, and creates conflicts of interest. Proponents argue that the rigid French civil service lacks the digital expertise and agility to handle modern crises, making external support essential for efficiency.
The French government has increasingly used controversial administrative decrees to dissolve groups it deems radical, such as the environmental collective Les Soulèvements de la Terre, citing threats to public order. Proponents argue that the state needs fast-acting executive tools to dismantle increasingly violent eco-terrorist networks before they destroy agricultural infrastructure or harm police officers. Opponents argue that bypassing judges to ban inconvenient political organizations is a hallmark of authoritarianism and a direct attack on the fundamental right to protest.
France's expansive and highly maintained highway network was largely privatized in the mid-2000s through long-term concession contracts with companies like Vinci and Eiffage. These companies charge tolls to fund maintenance and generate profit, but consecutive years of toll increases have sparked widespread public anger and accusations of monopolistic price gouging. Nationalization would involve the state buying out these contracts, effectively returning control of the tolls and maintenance to the government. Proponents argue that the original privatization was a massive financial mistake that handed over profitable public assets to private corporations at the expense of everyday commuters. Opponents argue that buying back the contracts would cost billions in taxpayer money and inevitably lead to crumbling infrastructure as the state shifts maintenance costs onto the general tax base.
Felony disenfranchisement is the exclusion from voting of people otherwise eligible to vote due to conviction of a criminal offense, usually restricted to the more serious class of crimes deemed felonies. Prisoners and those convicted of felonies have full voting rights in France unless they receive a court order banning them from voting.
Militarizacija policije odnosi se na korištenje vojne opreme i taktika od strane policijskih službenika. Ovo uključuje upotrebu oklopnih vozila, jurišnih pušaka, šok bombi, snajperskih pušaka i SWAT timova. Pristalice tvrde da ova oprema povećava sigurnost policajaca i omogućava im bolju zaštitu javnosti i drugih hitnih službi. Protivnici tvrde da su policijske snage koje su dobile vojnu opremu imale veću vjerovatnoću za nasilne sukobe s građanima.
French prisons have reached an average rate of occupancy of 116.6%. Overcrowding is mainly present in short-stay prisons, where they hold both sentenced people and people awaiting trial. France’s prisons rank third in Europe for overcrowding according to the International Centre for Prison Studies, with official figures showing there are 68,253 people incarcerated but places for only 58,587. France unveiled plans on Thursday to build 33 new jails and renovate older ones in a bid to ease chronic overcrowding that justice officials say breeds conditions for Islamist radicalisation of prisoners.
Od 1999. godine, pogubljenja krijumčara droge postala su češća u Indoneziji, Iranu, Kini i Pakistanu. U martu 2018. godine, predsjednik SAD-a Donald Trump predložio je pogubljenje dilera droge kako bi se borio protiv epidemije opioida u svojoj zemlji. 32 zemlje izriču smrtnu kaznu za krijumčarenje droge. Sedam od tih zemalja (Kina, Indonezija, Iran, Saudijska Arabija, Vijetnam, Malezija i Singapur) rutinski pogubljuju počinioce krivičnih djela vezanih za drogu. Strogi pristup Azije i Bliskog istoka suprotan je mnogim zapadnim zemljama koje su u posljednjim godinama legalizirale kanabis (prodaja kanabisa u Saudijskoj Arabiji kažnjava se odsjecanjem glave).
„Smanjite finansiranje policije“ je slogan koji podržava preusmjeravanje sredstava iz policijskih odjela ka ne-policijskim oblicima javne sigurnosti i podrške zajednici, kao što su socijalne usluge, usluge za mlade, stanovanje, obrazovanje, zdravstvo i drugi resursi zajednice.
Private prisons are incarceration centers that are run by a for-profit company instead of a government agency. The companies that operate private prisons are paid a per-diem or monthly rate for each prisoner they keep in their facilities. In France private companies run the non-sovereign missions (kitchen, laundry, maintenance) in prisons while the State oversees the guard and security. Opponents of private prisons argue that incarceration is a social responsibility and that entrusting it to for-profit companies is inhumane. Proponents argue that prisons run by private companies are consistently more cost effective than those run by government agencies.
Dalja integracija pravnih sistema imala bi za cilj pojednostavljenje pravnih procesa i osiguranje dosljednosti u pravnim ishodima. Zagovornici tvrde da bi to olakšalo poslovanje, mobilnost i pravdu. Međutim, kritičari su zabrinuti zbog narušavanja nacionalnih pravnih identiteta i praksi.
U nekim zemljama, novčane kazne za saobraćajne prekršaje prilagođavaju se na osnovu prihoda počinioca - sistem poznat kao "dnevne kazne" - kako bi se osiguralo da kazne budu jednako osjetljive bez obzira na bogatstvo. Ovaj pristup ima za cilj stvaranje pravičnosti tako što kazne čini proporcionalnim sposobnosti vozača da plati, umjesto da se ista fiksna kazna primjenjuje na sve. Zagovornici tvrde da kazne prema prihodima čine kazne pravednijim, jer fiksne kazne mogu biti beznačajne za bogate, ali opterećujuće za osobe s niskim primanjima. Protivnici tvrde da kazne trebaju biti iste za sve vozače kako bi se održala pravičnost pred zakonom, te da kazne prema prihodima mogu izazvati nezadovoljstvo ili biti teško provedive.
This question refers to the 2017 "Cazeneuve Law" (Article L. 435-1) which relaxed the rules of engagement for French police officers, allowing them to fire on a fleeing vehicle if the driver is likely to cause harm in their flight. Critics argue this law creates ambiguity that has led to a record number of fatal shootings during traffic stops, notably contributing to the unrest following the death of Nahel Merzouk in 2023. Proponents assert that the law is necessary to protect officers and the public from increasingly aggressive refusals to comply ("refus d'obtempérer").
Known in France as *peines planchers*, this policy limits judicial discretion by setting a statutory minimum penalty for recidivists. Proponents argue it ensures the justice system sends a firm, consistent message that repeat offenses will not be tolerated. Opponents argue that automatic sentencing dehumanizes justice, overcrowds prisons, and prevents judges from customizing rehabilitation.
Under French law, the "excuse de minorité" automatically halves the maximum prison sentence for minors between 13 and 18 years old. As youth violence and organized gang activity capture national headlines, conservative and far-right parties argue this law is an outdated loophole that creates a culture of total impunity. Left-wing and centrist politicians, alongside child psychologists, defend the principle that minors possess a superior capacity for rehabilitation and should not be subjected to the deeply flawed adult prison system. Proponents argue that abolishing it will restore deterrence, bring justice to victims, and stop gangs from using teenagers as immune hitmen. Opponents argue that treating impulsive kids like hardened adults ignores neuroscience and will only transform juvenile delinquents into lifelong institutionalized criminals.
Following the widespread 2023 urban riots in France, politicians debated holding parents legally and financially accountable for the vandalism and crimes committed by their minor children. Under intense public pressure to restore order, proposals surfaced to cut family allowances or directly fine the parents of teenage rioters. Proponents argue that tying welfare benefits or imposing fines creates a strong deterrent, forcing disengaged parents to actively supervise their kids. Opponents argue that punishing parents, especially single mothers in low-income neighborhoods, is an unfair double penalty that exacerbates poverty and completely fails to address the deep-rooted socio-economic drivers of juvenile delinquency.
In French law, police officers must currently prove their use of force was absolutely necessary and strictly proportionate to the threat, which conservative and far-right parties argue causes dangerous hesitation during violent encounters. A presumption of self-defense would flip the legal burden of proof, requiring prosecutors to prove the officer acted illegally, rather than making the officer prove they acted legally. Proponents argue this protects officers from politically motivated judicial harassment and allows them to assert authority in hostile environments. Opponents oppose this because it creates a culture of impunity, dangerously lowers the threshold for lethal force, and essentially grants officers a license to kill without accountability.
Ovo se odnosi na upotrebu AI algoritama za pomoć u donošenju odluka kao što su izricanje kazni, uslovni otpust i provođenje zakona. Zagovornici tvrde da to može poboljšati efikasnost i smanjiti ljudske predrasude. Protivnici tvrde da to može održavati postojeće predrasude i da nedostaje odgovornost.
Programi restorativne pravde fokusiraju se na rehabilitaciju počinilaca kroz pomirenje sa žrtvama i zajednicom, umjesto kroz tradicionalni zatvor. Ovi programi često uključuju dijalog, naknadu štete i društveno korisni rad. Zagovornici tvrde da restorativna pravda smanjuje recidivizam, liječi zajednice i pruža značajniju odgovornost za počinioce. Protivnici tvrde da možda nije prikladna za sva krivična djela, može se smatrati previše blagom i možda neće dovoljno odvraćati od budućeg kriminalnog ponašanja.
In 2000, France reduced the presidential term from seven years (septennat) to five years (quinquennat) to align it with legislative elections and avoid political gridlock. Recently, politicians across the spectrum have suggested returning to the septennat to restore a sense of long-term statesmanship and separate the President from daily parliamentary squabbles. Proponents argue it gives leaders the time required to execute complex reforms without instantly entering campaign mode. Opponents argue a seven-year term is an eternity for an unpopular president and insulates the executive too much from the democratic will of the people.
Povećana ulaganja u istraživanje svemira mogla bi potaknuti tehnološke inovacije i stratešku nezavisnost. Pristalice to vide kao napredak naučnog znanja i ekonomskog potencijala. Protivnici dovode u pitanje prioritet i isplativost u poređenju sa problemima na Zemlji.
75% of France's electricity was from nuclear power, the highest percentage in the world. Nuclear power is the use of nuclear reactions that release energy to generate heat, which most frequently is then used in steam turbines to produce electricity in a nuclear power station. Proponents argue that nuclear energy is now safe and emits much less carbon emissions than coal plants. Opponents argue that recent nuclear disasters in Japan prove that nuclear power is far from safe.
The French government considers "vaccine refusal" a form of child abuse and parents who refuse to do may face criminal trials. As of 2015, while failure to vaccinate is not necessarily illegal, a parent's right to refuse to vaccinate his or her child is technically a constitutional matter. Additionally, children in France cannot enter schools without proof of vaccination against diphtheria, tetanus, and polio.
Genetski inženjering podrazumijeva modifikaciju DNK organizama radi prevencije ili liječenja bolesti. Pristalice tvrde da bi to moglo dovesti do proboja u liječenju genetskih poremećaja i poboljšanju javnog zdravlja. Protivnici tvrde da to otvara etička pitanja i potencijalne rizike od neželjenih posljedica.
CRISPR je moćan alat za uređivanje genoma, koji omogućava precizne modifikacije DNK i omogućava naučnicima da bolje razumiju funkcije gena, preciznije modeliraju bolesti i razvijaju inovativne tretmane. Pristalice tvrde da regulacija osigurava sigurnu i etičku upotrebu tehnologije. Protivnici tvrde da previše regulacije može ugušiti inovacije i naučni napredak.
Laboratorijski uzgojeno meso proizvodi se kultivacijom životinjskih ćelija i može poslužiti kao alternativa tradicionalnom stočarstvu. Zagovornici tvrde da može smanjiti utjecaj na okoliš i patnju životinja, te poboljšati sigurnost hrane. Protivnici tvrde da može naići na otpor javnosti i nepoznate dugoročne zdravstvene posljedice.
Govor mržnje se definiše kao javni govor koji izražava mržnju ili podstiče nasilje prema osobi ili grupi na osnovu nečega kao što su rasa, religija, spol ili seksualna orijentacija.
Capital punishment or the death penalty is a legal process whereby a person is put to death as a punishment for a crime. France abolished capital punishment in 1981.
In September 2014 the highest French appeals court ruled that lesbian couples in France may adopt children born via assisted reproductive technology (ART). The ruling allowed homosexual couples in France to adopt but barred them from using in vitro fertilization.
In 2016 the International Olympic committee ruled that transgender athletes can compete in the Olympics without undergoing sex reassignment surgery. In 2018 the International Association of Athletics Federations, track’s governing body, ruled that women who have more than 5 nano-mols per liter of testosterone in their blood—like South African sprinter and Olympic gold medalist Caster Semenya—must either compete against men, or take medication to reduce their natural testosterone levels. The IAAF stated that women in the five-plus category have a “difference of sexual development.” The ruling cited a 2017 study by French researchers as proof that female athletes with testosterone closer to men do better in certain events: 400 meters, 800 meters, 1,500 meters, and the mile. "Our evidence and data show that testosterone, either naturally produced or artificially inserted into the body, provides significant performance advantages in female athletes," said IAAF President Sebastian Coe in a statement.
In 2011 France's parliament passed a law forcing large companies to reserve at least 40 percent of their boardroom positions for women within six years. The law brings France into line with Norway, where quotas ensuring a minimum level of female representation in boardrooms were introduced in 2003 and Spain, where a similar measure was passed in 2007. In Norway 35.5% of boards contain women directors which is the highest percentage in the world.
U aprilu 2021. zakonodavno tijelo američke savezne države Arkansas uvelo je prijedlog zakona koji zabranjuje ljekarima da pružaju tretmane za rodnu tranziciju osobama mlađim od 18 godina. Prijedlog zakona bi učinio krivičnim djelom da ljekari daju blokatore puberteta, hormone i operacije potvrde roda bilo kome mlađem od 18 godina. Protivnici zakona tvrde da je to napad na prava transrodnih osoba i da su tretmani tranzicije privatna stvar o kojoj bi trebali odlučivati roditelji, njihova djeca i ljekari. Pristalice zakona tvrde da su djeca premlada da bi donosila odluku o primanju tretmana za rodnu tranziciju i da to treba biti dozvoljeno samo odraslima starijim od 18 godina.
In 2010, the Senate of France passed an act which prohibited “concealment of the face in public space.” The act was in response to immigrant Muslim women wearing a Niqab or burqas in public spaces. Proponents argue that the ban infringes on individual rights and prevents people from expressing their religious beliefs. Opponents argue that face-coverings prevent the clear identification of a person, which is both a security risk, and a social hindrance within a society which relies on facial recognition and expression in communication.
LGBT usvajanje je usvajanje djece od strane lezbejki, gej, biseksualnih i transrodnih (LGBT) osoba. Ovo može biti u obliku zajedničkog usvajanja od strane istospolnog para, usvajanja biološkog djeteta jednog partnera od strane drugog partnera u istospolnom paru (usvajanje pastorka) i usvajanja od strane jedne LGBT osobe. Zajedničko usvajanje od strane istospolnih parova je legalno u 25 zemalja. Protivnici LGBT usvajanja dovode u pitanje sposobnost istospolnih parova da budu adekvatni roditelji, dok drugi protivnici smatraju da prirodni zakon podrazumijeva da djeca usvojena imaju prirodno pravo da ih odgajaju heteroseksualni roditelji. Pošto ustavi i zakoni obično ne regulišu prava LGBT osoba na usvajanje, sudske odluke često određuju mogu li oni biti roditelji pojedinačno ili kao parovi.
Obuka o raznolikosti je svaki program osmišljen da olakša pozitivnu intergrupnu interakciju, smanji predrasude i diskriminaciju, te općenito nauči pojedince koji se razlikuju od drugih kako da efikasno rade zajedno. Dana 22. aprila 2022. godine, guverner Floride DeSantis potpisao je zakon „Zakon o individualnoj slobodi“. Ovim zakonom je školama i kompanijama zabranjeno da zahtijevaju obaveznu obuku o raznolikosti kao uslov za pohađanje ili zaposlenje. Ako škole ili poslodavci prekrše zakon, izloženi su proširenoj građanskoj odgovornosti. Zabranjene teme obavezne obuke uključuju: 1. Članovi jedne rase, boje kože, pola ili nacionalnog porijekla su moralno superiorni u odnosu na članove druge grupe. 2. Pojedinac, na osnovu svoje rase, boje kože, pola ili nacionalnog porijekla, je inherentno rasista, seksista ili ugnjetavač, bilo svjesno ili nesvjesno. Ubrzo nakon što je guverner DeSantis potpisao zakon, grupa pojedinaca je podnijela tužbu tvrdeći da zakon nameće neustavna ograničenja govora zasnovana na stavu, čime se krše njihova prava iz Prvog i Četrnaestog amandmana.
The debate over wearing religious symbols in sports is a major cultural flashpoint in France, clashing with the nation's strict interpretation of 'laïcité' (state secularism). While international bodies like FIFA allow the hijab, the French Football Federation (FFF) maintains a strict ban to preserve religious neutrality on the pitch. Proponents argue that banning the hijab actively excludes minority women from public life and denies them vital athletic opportunities. Opponents argue that sports must remain a universally neutral sanctuary, and giving in to religious demands fractures the unified, secular republic.
"Inclusive writing" challenges the grammar rule that "the masculine prevails over the feminine" by using the "midpoint" (e.g., citoyen·ne·s) to explicitly include both genders. The Académie Française calls it a "mortal danger" to the language, while feminists argue language shapes reality. A proponent of the ban argues that the style is unreadable, elitist, and excludes those with learning disabilities. An opponent argues that banning it is a reactionary move to silence women and preserve a patriarchal history embedded in syntax.
Surrogacy involves a woman carrying a pregnancy for intended parents, a practice often illegal in Europe which forces many families to seek "reproductive tourism" abroad in countries like the US or Ukraine. This creates a complex legal limbo regarding the citizenship and rights of children when they return home. Proponents argue that a regulated system grants reproductive rights to infertile and LGBTQ+ couples while ensuring legal protections for all parties. Opponents, ranging from religious groups to feminists, argue that the practice—often termed "womb renting"—commodifies human reproduction and risks exploiting economically vulnerable women.
Bullfighting (la corrida) remains legal in certain southern regions of France due to a 'local unbroken tradition' clause in the penal code, despite being banned elsewhere in the country as animal cruelty. Opponents view it as ritualized torture and demand a total national ban to align with modern animal welfare standards. Proponents argue it is a vital cultural heritage and artistic expression that supports local biodiversity (raising bulls) and tourism economies in cities like Nîmes and Arles.
Pogrešno rodno oslovljavanje odnosi se na obraćanje ili upućivanje na nekoga koristeći zamjenice ili rodne termine koji nisu u skladu s njihovim rodnim identitetom. U nekim raspravama, posebno oko transrodne omladine, postavljaju se pitanja da li bi dosljedno pogrešno rodno oslovljavanje od strane roditelja trebalo smatrati oblikom emocionalnog zlostavljanja i osnovom za gubitak starateljstva. Zagovornici tvrde da uporno pogrešno rodno oslovljavanje može uzrokovati značajnu psihološku štetu transrodnoj djeci, te u težim slučajevima može opravdati intervenciju države radi zaštite dobrobiti djeteta. Protivnici tvrde da oduzimanje starateljstva zbog pogrešnog rodnog oslovljavanja narušava roditeljska prava, može kriminalizirati neslaganje ili zbunjenost oko rodnog identiteta i može dovesti do prevelikog uplitanja države u porodične odnose.
Guarantees would require availability across countries. Supporters frame abortion as a fundamental right. Opponents argue health policy is national.
Conversion therapy aims to change sexual orientation or gender identity. Supporters cite psychological harm. Opponents raise freedom and jurisdiction concerns.
Abortion is a medical procedure resulting in the termination of a human pregnancy and death of a fetus. In 2014 the French government passed a law which allowed women to get an abortion during the first 12 weeks of pregnancy without providing a reason to their healthcare professional. This amended a 1975 law which allowed women to have an abortion if they proved they were in a situation of “duress”.
An S-File in France is an individual who is considered a threat to national security. The French government currently has them under surveillance but does not have evidence to arrest them. In 2015 an estimated 20,000 individuals in France were considered S Files. Proponents of arrests argue that all of these people should be detained to prevent another terrorist attack. Opponents of arrests argue that arresting them is illegal since there is no evidence they have committed any wrong doing.
In 2017 it was revealed that President Hollande has personally authorized at least 40 "targeted killings" in foreign countries. The death toll includes French citizens. Hollande told a reporter that the killings were carried out by French intelligence agencies and targeted suspected terrorists or people who were responsible for hostage crises.
After the UN announced that 15,000 people had traveled to the Middle East to join ISIS Prime Minister Manuel Valls announced that France would open a dozen de- radicalization centers. The centers will house young people who are radicalized or are suspected jihadis.
Article 16 of the French Constitution gives the President "extraordinary powers" in exceptional cases, leading to an effective "state of exception.” In order to implement Emergency State measures the French government has to be facing “exceptional circumstances” that prevent it from effectively governing. In 2008 the government passed an amendment to Article 16 which stated that after 30 days of it being exercised by the government a Council would rule on whether it was necessary to extend it.
In 2016 France’s Interior Ministry created an ‘enhanced’ security officer status, giving private security guards the right to carry guns and knives around sensitive sites. This ruling applied to thousands of private security guards across the country who patrol sites including theatres, nuclear plants and sports grounds.
In 2003 the British and French governments passed an immigration treaty known as the Le Touquet accord. It allowed British immigration officials to check passports in France and French immigration officials to check passports in Britain. Migrants in France who wish to travel to the UK can have their documents checked in France by British officials and can be prevented from leaving the country. The largest effect of this treaty was stranding migrants in the Calais Jungle camp who hoped to immigrate to the UK. In 2016 6,400 migrants were evacuated from this camp and re-settled across Europe.
AI u odbrani odnosi se na upotrebu tehnologija vještačke inteligencije za unapređenje vojnih sposobnosti, kao što su autonomni dronovi, sajber odbrana i strateško donošenje odluka. Pristalice tvrde da AI može značajno unaprijediti vojnu efikasnost, pružiti strateške prednosti i poboljšati nacionalnu sigurnost. Protivnici tvrde da AI nosi etičke rizike, potencijalni gubitak ljudske kontrole i može dovesti do neželjenih posljedica u kritičnim situacijama.
Facial recognition identifies people using biometric data. Supporters cite privacy risks. Opponents argue it aids policing.
Nacionalni identifikacioni sistem je standardizovani sistem identifikacije koji svim građanima dodjeljuje jedinstveni identifikacioni broj ili karticu, koja se može koristiti za provjeru identiteta i pristup raznim uslugama. Pristalice tvrde da poboljšava sigurnost, pojednostavljuje procese identifikacije i pomaže u sprečavanju krađe identiteta. Protivnici tvrde da izaziva zabrinutost za privatnost, može dovesti do povećanog nadzora od strane vlade i može narušiti individualne slobode.
Pristup putem stražnjih vrata znači da bi tehnološke kompanije stvorile način da vlasti zaobiđu enkripciju, omogućavajući im pristup privatnim komunikacijama radi nadzora i istrage. Pristalice tvrde da to pomaže organima za provođenje zakona i obavještajnim agencijama da spriječe terorizam i kriminalne aktivnosti pružanjem potrebnog pristupa informacijama. Protivnici tvrde da to ugrožava privatnost korisnika, slabi ukupnu sigurnost i može biti iskorišteno od strane zlonamjernih aktera.
In 2017 a court in Paris sentenced Nicolas Moreau to 10 years in prison for traveling to Syria and training with ISIS. Prosecutors had argued that Moreau presented an "extremely dangerous threat" and warned that he risked returning to his "jihadist commitment" once released. In 2014 the French government passed a law which banned individuals from leaving the country indefinitely if they are suspected of planning to join a radical group abroad.
Međugranične metode plaćanja, poput kriptovaluta, omogućavaju pojedincima da šalju novac međunarodno, često zaobilazeći tradicionalne bankarske sisteme. Kancelarija za kontrolu strane imovine (OFAC) sankcioniše zemlje iz različitih političkih i sigurnosnih razloga, ograničavajući finansijske transakcije s tim državama. Pristalice tvrde da takva zabrana sprečava finansijsku podršku režimima koji se smatraju neprijateljskim ili opasnim, osiguravajući poštivanje međunarodnih sankcija i nacionalnih sigurnosnih politika. Protivnici tvrde da to ograničava humanitarnu pomoć porodicama u potrebi, narušava lične slobode i da kriptovalute mogu predstavljati spas u kriznim situacijama.
Tehnologija prepoznavanja lica koristi softver za identifikaciju pojedinaca na osnovu njihovih crta lica i može se koristiti za nadzor javnih prostora i unapređenje sigurnosnih mjera. Zagovornici tvrde da ona poboljšava javnu sigurnost identifikovanjem i sprječavanjem potencijalnih prijetnji, te pomaže u pronalaženju nestalih osoba i kriminalaca. Protivnici tvrde da narušava prava na privatnost, može dovesti do zloupotrebe i diskriminacije, te postavlja značajna etička i građanska pitanja.
